Electric Trio: Examining Ola S1 Air, Simple Dot One, and Ather 450X for Urban Commuting

In recent years, the electric scooter market has witnessed remarkable growth, offering eco-friendly and technologically advanced options. Among the key players, Ola Electric, Simple Energy, and Ather Energy have emerged with distinct models - the Ola S1 Air, Simple Dot One, and Ather 450X.

This comprehensive comparison aims to explore the specifications, features, and overall offerings of these electric scooters, aiding potential buyers in making an informed decision accordingly.

Tech & Design

Ola S1 Air

It has a feature-packed design with iconic elements like a dual-tone body, flat footboard, stronger grab rail, and a spacious 34L boot space. The scooter aims to provide a visually appealing and functional riding experience with its moon-like headlamp, dual-tone color options, and a flat footboard for added convenience.

 

Simple Dot One

Simple Energy enters the electric scooter market with the Dot One, emphasizing simplicity and efficiency. With a certified range of 151 km, achieving a speed of 0-40 km/h in just 2.77 seconds, and with a top speed of 105 km/h, it positions itself as a tech-smart option for those that are seeking a straightforward and reliable electric scooter.

 

Ather 450X

Ather Energy introduces the new 450 Series with the Ather 450X, focusing on delivering a powerful and thrilling riding experience. Featuring a 2.9 kWh or 3.7 kWh battery, the scooter accelerates from 0-40 km/h in just 2.9 seconds and offers a top speed of 90 km/h. It positions itself as a premium option for enthusiasts who are seeking performance.

Software

Ola S1 Air

Enabled by MoveOS, the Ola S1 Air introduces advanced technological features. Proximity unlock, rider profiles, access controls, and an Ola Electric app provide users with a seamless and personalized riding experience. Additional features like Party Mode, Energy Insight, Navigation with Ola Maps, Eco Mode, and Moods that adds a layer of sophistication to the scooter's software.

 

 

Simple Dot One

It introduces a companion mobile app for enhancing the rider's experience. The app includes remote access, Simple Tag, OTA updates, route saving and forwarding, ride statistics, and remote alerts. This emphasis on connectivity aims to make the rider's journey more convenient and connected.

 

Ather 450X

It introduces an industry-first touchscreen dashboard with features like Google Maps, Bluetooth for call and music control, OTA updates, interactive UI, and TrueRange for intelligent range prediction. The DeepView Display provides turn-by-turn navigation, creating a connected riding experience.

Ownership

Ola S1 Air

Ola emphasizes the ownership benefits of choosing an electric vehicle, highlighting the annual savings of ₹22,032 and monthly savings of ₹1,836. The scooter offers financing options starting at ₹2,699/month, making it an attractive and cost-effective choice for urban commuters.

 

Simple Dot One

Simple Energy focuses on making the ownership experience hassle-free. It offers financing options with EMIs starting at ₹2,099/month. The company has partnered with various banks, simplifying the financing process for potential buyers. The Split and Pay feature allows for the users to customize the payment options, providing flexibility.

 

Ather 450X

Ather Energy provides a portable charger that can be plugged into any 5A socket for convenient charging at home or away. The Ather Grid, with 1400+ charging points, forms India's largest and fastest-growing charging network.

 

Experience Centre and Accessories

Ola S1 Air

To enhance the customer experience, Ola Electric has set up Experience Centres where potential buyers can explore the scooters, understand their features, and even take them for a test ride. The company aims to provide a hands-on experience to potential customers to facilitate an informed decision-making process.

 

Simple Dot One

It positions itself as an intuitively designed and tech-smart electric scooter, serving users who prioritize simplicity, efficiency, and connectivity in their urban commuting experience.

 

Ather 450X

Ather offers a range of accessories, including A&M + Forum Ather TPMS, Ather Side Step, Ather Helmets, Ather Frunk, and more. The Ather Forum serves as an online community where owners can share their experiences, reviews, and information.

Safety and Performance

Ola S1 Air

Safety features include robust build quality, but specific details are not specified. The scooter also offers a top speed of 90 km/h and a peak power of 6 kW, providing a reliable and efficient performance for urban commuting.

 

Simple Dot One

Safety features include a CBS braking system, ensuring a stopping distance of 27 meters. With a top speed of 105 km/h and a peak power of 8.5 kW, the scooter aims to deliver a secure and powerful riding experience.

 

Ather 450X

Safety is a priority for Ather 450X, featuring an emergency stop signal, FallSafe technology, dual disc brakes, and a quick 60-0 km/h braking distance in less than 2 seconds. The scooter ensures a safe and controlled riding experience for the rider.

 

Accessories

Ola S1 Air

It features the Hypercharger network for convenient charging, but specific charging time details are not specified. The scooter does not mention specific accessories.

 

Simple Dot One

It does not specify details about its charging infrastructure or additional accessories.

 

Ather 450X

Ather Energy provides a portable charger for convenient charging at home or away, with specific charging times mentioned. The Ather Grid, with 1400+ charging points, forms India's largest and fastest-growing charging network. It offers a range of accessories, including A&M + Forum Ather TPMS, Ather Side Step, Ather Helmets, Ather Frunk, and more.

Performance Metrics

Ola S1 Air

It offers a certified range of 151 km, a top speed of 90 km/h, and a peak power of 6 kW. Charging time is specified at 5 hours, and other performance details are not explicitly provided.

 

Simple Dot One

It matches the Ola S1 Air with a certified range of 151 km. However, it surpasses it with a higher top speed of 105 km/h and a peak power of 8.5 kW. Specifics on charging time are not available.

 

Ather 450X

It provides a certified range of 115 km (2.9 kWh) to 150 km (3.7 kWh), a top speed of 90 km/h, and a peak power of 6.4 kW. Charging times are specified at 6 hours 36 minutes for the 2.9 kWh variant and 8 hours 36 minutes for the 3.7 kWh variant.

Connectivity and Technology

Ola S1 Air

It boasts connectivity features through the Ola Electric App, offering proximity unlocking, rider profiles, access controls, and additional features like Party Mode, Energy Insight, Navigation with Ola Maps, Eco Mode, and Moods.

 

Simple Dot One

It introduces a companion mobile app, enhancing the rider's experience with remote access, Simple Tag, OTA updates, route saving and forwarding, ride statistics, and remote alerts.

 

Ather 450X

 

It introduces an industry-first touchscreen dashboard with features like Google Maps, Bluetooth for call and music control, OTA updates, interactive UI, and TrueRange for intelligent range prediction.

Community Engagement

Ola S1 Air

Ola Electric engages with potential buyers through Experience Centres, providing hands-on exploration of the scooter. However, specific community engagement details are not provided.

 

Simple Dot One

The Simple Dot One positions itself as an intuitively designed and tech-smart electric scooter, catering to users who prioritize simplicity, efficiency, and connectivity in their urban commuting experience.

 

Ather 450X

The Ather Forum serves as an online community where owners can share experiences, reviews, and information.

Comparison Table

Let's summarize the key specifications and features of each electric scooter in a detailed comparison table: