Renault Duster vs Tata Sierra: Bharat NCAP Safety Scores Compared

The Renault Duster and Tata Sierra have both achieved five-star ratings in Bharat NCAP crash tests. These results highlight their strong safety credentials. However, a closer look at the detailed scores reveals subtle differences between the two SUVs.

Key Highlights

• Renault Duster and Tata Sierra both receive five-star Bharat NCAP safety ratings
• Duster scores 30.49 out of 32 for adult protection and 45 out of 49 for child safety
• Sierra leads with 31.14 out of 32 for adult protection and scores 44.73 out of 49 for child safety
• Both SUVs offer multiple airbags, ESC, seat belt reminders and ISOFIX mounts as standard

Adult and Child Occupant Protection

The Renault Duster scored 30.49 out of 32 in adult occupant protection. In the frontal offset deformable barrier test, it achieved 14.49 out of 16. This indicates good structural integrity, though not the highest in its class. The Duster excelled in the side impact test, earning a perfect 16 out of 16, and also performed well in the side pole test.

For child occupant protection, the Duster scored 45 out of 49. It received full marks in both dynamic testing and child restraint system (CRS) installation. This makes it a strong choice for families prioritizing child safety.

The Tata Sierra slightly outperformed the Duster in adult protection, with a score of 31.14 out of 32. In the frontal offset crash test, the Sierra scored 15.14 out of 16, suggesting better impact management in frontal collisions. The side impact test results matched the Duster, with a full 16 out of 16 and a successful pole test outcome.

In child occupant protection, the Sierra scored 44.73 out of 49. This is marginally lower than the Duster, but the difference is minimal for most buyers.

Safety Features and Equipment

Both SUVs include a comprehensive set of safety features. The Renault Duster offers multiple airbags, electronic stability control (ESC), seat belt reminders for all occupants, and pedestrian protection systems as standard. The Tata Sierra provides similar features, with multiple airbags, ESC, and seat belt reminders across its variants.

Both vehicles also come equipped with ISOFIX mounts, anti-lock braking system (ABS) with electronic brakeforce distribution (EBD), traction control, and other essential safety systems expected in this segment.

Market Position and Alternatives

The Renault Duster and Tata Sierra both deliver strong safety performance, making them competitive choices in the compact SUV segment. The Sierra holds a slight advantage in adult occupant protection, while the Duster leads in child safety scores.

Other compact SUVs in this segment include the Hyundai Creta, Kia Seltos, Toyota Hyryder, Maruti Grand Vitara, Maruti Victoris, Skoda Kushaq Facelift, MG Astor, Honda Elevate, and Volkswagen Taigun. Buyers may also consider these models when comparing safety features and overall value.